1 Hotels in Shelter Island (NY), United States. Best Hotels in Shelter Island (NY)

This website uses cookies, which are necessary to its functioning and the best possible experience. By closing this banner, clicking a link, or continuing to browse otherwise, you agree to the use of cookies. Learn more

Pattaya
Tokyo
Berlin
Paris
New York

Home
Shelter Island (NY)

1 Hotels in Shelter Island (NY)

Your budget (per night)

US$175 - US$175

Filter by Star Rating

★★★★★

★★★★

★★★

★★

★

Filter by User Rating

Exceptional 9+

Very good 8+

Good 7+

Pleasant 6+

Filters

Clear all filters

Journey By Heart offers over 300,000 Hotels in 25,000 cities across the world.

Resources

How we work
Loyalty Program
Travel News
Blog

Company

About Us
Careers
Contact
FAQs

Legal

Privacy Policy
Terms of Service

© 2025 JourneyByHeart. All rights reserved.

Back to top ↑

Disclaimer
Rates are subject to change without notice. Journey By Heart is not responsible if there are changes made by hotel to your reservation. Journey By Heart does not guarantee that you will get your room after reservation. Please check with the company that sends you the confirmation email. Journey By Heart also does not offer room bookings. We help travelers find suitable rooms. Hotel reserves the right to deny you room. Please make sure that you read the Terms and conditions on your confirmation voucher before starting to travel and your stay at the hotel.